Bronx+Brooklyn(only) vs any american city? (state, population, Los Angeles)

[K.O.N.Y]

If the bx and brooklyn were a city by itself how would it stack up against americas greatest cities. Discuss and disregard manhattan,queens and staten island

[nashvols]

Dead last.

[K.O.N.Y]

Doubt it. The combination between them two would make the biggest city in america. With world class institutions to boot

[nashvols]

Originally Posted by K.O.N.Y

Doubt it. The combination between them two would make the biggest city in america. With world class institutions to boot

Neat.

[HAC NY]

Oh, God...not another one of these threads...

Answer: It wouldn't be the greatest city in the world anymore. Regardless of population, it would be behind San Francisco, Boston, Los Angeles, Chicago and Washington.

You're just opening yourself up for bashing w/ threads like this BTW.

[StreetBAller85]

it would win the competition of most grimey dudes per capita and most grimey dudes overall

[MPC]

Originally Posted by K.O.N.Y

Doubt it. The combination between them two would make the biggest city in america. With world class institutions to boot

If Manhattan, Queens & Staten Island were still NY, it would be #2, not #1 biggest, only behind NYC lol

[foadi]

if derpa derp, then herpity derpity derp derp derp

[Galactic]

Losing Manhattan would be a huge blow. When the rest of the world thinks of NYC, most of them think about Times Square and Wall Street.

My parents live in Staten Island, I go there often, and it might as well be a part of New Jersey as far as I'm concerned. It's nothing like the other 4 boroughs.

[Observation]

It would be probably the most dirty ghetto of a large city with the worst skyline.
Brooklyns skyline rivals Tulsa, or Boise.