Quote:
Originally Posted by thrillobyte
I can't think of a single instance where a Biblical promise was kept--in any way that be conclusively demonstrated, that is.
|
The question is always how to interpret what the promise means, and who and to how it is applied.
There are many very detailed, elaborate, lavish promises of divine largesse for the faithful. When an individual life happens to align with these promises, it can always be claimed that the promise was fulfilled for them, because this person was sufficiently pious / observant / worthy; when it doesn't happen, it is never god's fault somehow.
That is why general promises of nonspecific "blessing" (blessed are peace-makers, god blesses the righteous and confounds the wicked) are basically meaningless; something as innocuous as being employed or in good health or having love in your life could be styled as "god's blessing". So it is no real incentive to goodness. In any case, REAL goodness is what you practice when there's nothing in it for you.
It is also clear that often enough in life, the wicked prosper and the good are confounded. Right now there are plenty of perfectly saintly people suffering terribly in places like Ukraine and Yemen and Palestine. And there are evil sociopaths prospering off their suffering, too.
So all of these claims of "fulfilled promises" are very much like claims of "fulfilled prophecies" -- our eager pattern-matching brains can easily map random events to these "fulfillments" we are claiming.
If the Bible promised something unambiguous, such as that EVERY person who places ANY level of trust in god will always get a free car that never wears out unless they renounce their faith, at which point it quits working or turns into a pumpkin, then that would be easily verified empirical proof of the promises of god.
As it is, we ultimately have nothing but anecdotes and campfire stories, as usual.