Hey, I'm even older than you are (68), and I can relate. I had to end my subscription to
Rolling Stone when the rock stars they were writing about were mostly acts I'd never heard of or whose music didn't appeal to me. When the Top 100 list started to look like "Top 100 Songs Bayarea4 Has Never Heard Of," I knew I was officially turning into a geezer. And that was way back in the 1980s!
I mostly listen to oldies these days.