Best Pizza in the Southern Tier? (Binghamton, Vestal: neighborhood, shops, places)

[JimCali]

I'm ready to explore new pizza places beyond my neighborhood in Binghamton. Any suggestions where to go?

[phaelon56]

You could always try the self proclaimed "Pizza Capital of the World" in nearby Old Forge PA. It's not far from Binghamton and I'll reserve judgment because I haven't yet tried it. But apparently it's a style of pizza that's quite different from what most of us think of as the norm and may not be "all that". But there are a large number of pizza shops there for a small town.

Here's an interesting discussion of Old Forge PA pizza:

Old Forge, Pa: Pizza capital of the world

[Tioga]

If you don't want to make a trek all the way to Old Forge Pa., start with Consol's on Oak Hill Ave in Endicott.

[Mercator Projection]

Yeah, Consol's in Endicott is pretty amazing. Its grilled. Yummmm.

For a more traditional pizza, I always liked Mario's over in the Vestal Plaza. They have some incredible garlic knots, too.

[JimCali]

Thanks for the tips. Endicott is closer than Old Forge so I'll start with Consol's...:-)

Old Forge sounds great so it'll make a nice trip this summer.

[moucon]

Corning NY - Aniello's and Rico's - both very good thin-crust.
-Moo

[chunkysmom3502]

Roma's outside of Endicott is very good and a Pudgies just opened up in Binghamton if you haven't tried it yet I'd say go for it.

[Hartwick]

Brozetti's, next to Wilson Memorial Hospital, in Johnson City, NY.

[annerk]

My husband swears by Nirchi's in Endicott, but it doesn't float my boat.

[amazingj]

Consol's in Endicott is the best! Get it 'crispy'.