Gresford...did you read the original post ?? it said "(so no TGIF's or Applebees)"
Both couples are traveling and want to meet 1/2 way at approx Flemington...so they don't know the area...
So why would you recommend a number of places that would be flattered if someone said they were better than TGIF's or Applebees ?
Because of my GF's work schedule (gets home +/- an hr or so) we eat out a LOT. Nearly all of the places you mentined are fine for that...but that's NOT what Tahiti was asking for.
California Grill Yes great salads...NO atmosphere whats so ever unless you consider sitting next to a very large fish aquarium charming. It's NOT where you go for mother's day.
Alfonso’s and Capo Ristorante Capo, havn't been there yet, it's almost new but I'm suspect of resturants in strip malls. Alfonso's..this is without a doubt the worst. I don't even go there at all !!... It's a pizza place that also serves pasta etc. It has the worst interior of any of the places you mentioned. The food is cheap but very very forgettable. The place is frequented by soccer moms with the kids right from a game still in uniform etc. Many of the parents seem to feel we All want to get to know their little devils so they let them run around. And if you're lucky enough to get a table near the right rear area you get to partake of the bathroom traffic visa the delicate aroma of the mens room urinal deordorant tablets.!! Great.
Main street and Max's are much more on point. Outdoor seating at Max's etc. But... they are as you said on main street. While that may not be a problem for you and I consider that these folks are coming from out of town. You and I both know there is almost NO parking to be had near by. We know that you can park down near the junction and walk up to the places. (a real good block or two) For those not familiar with the area to hike 2 blocks
(in the rain maybe ??) is ridiculous.
Seargentsville Inn and the Clinton Inn: Clinton Inn..never been there , a little far. Seargentsville Inn.... now you've got it. I would recomend it also.
Tahiti :Also check this place out....it's in Hopewell, 5 miles S of Flemington. Nice safe area...can antique shop down town. Make sure you make reseravtions early. It's small and popular, really great food. Even on a week night you can't do a walk in.
http://www.thebluebottlecafe.com/