Quote:
Originally Posted by zulu400
Hi everyone,
Can you guys suggest a dependable tent for a family of 4.
A screened porch will be a plus, but we can live without it. We probably will use it twice a year and mostly in the summers, so no need for 3 season durability (just saying).
I would be happy if it can withstand the wind and rain (very important) reasonably well.
Will be camping mostly in the tristate area.
|
Wow, there's not much to go on here...
Quote:
Originally Posted by zulu400
I would be happy if it can withstand the wind and rain (very important) reasonably well.
|
When you say it should withstand wind and rain, what type of wind and rain are you talking about?
In some areas, a 30 MPH gust is as much wind as you're likely to encounter, while in other areas, 30 MPH is a light breeze... As for rain, are you talking a 15 minute shower during the summer, or the kind or torrential downpour that comes from a monsoonal type of storm?
Quote:
Originally Posted by zulu400
Will be camping mostly in the tristate area.
|
When you mention the "tristate" area, is that WY, SD, NE? AZ, NV, UT? ID, WY, MT? WV, OH, PA? AR, TX, LA? Your post did not indicate which area you were in. It is difficult to know what type of weather to expect in your area considering we don't know what your area is...
Edit: I saw in your profile that your location is New York, but this still doesn't tell me much about the "tristate" area in which you plan to camp...
As for the suggestions of a Walmart or Sears tent, yes they are adequate for camping in many areas during the summer. I've had several of them, all of which have served me (and others) well. I still have most of them, or have passed them on to others who still have them.
The only problems I ever had with any of them were due to either age or wind.
One Walmart cabin tent that I had failed after being set up in the yard for several months, for the kids to play in. I believe it was done in when the snow fell on it, which it wasn't strong enough to handle, especially after months of being exposed to the sun.
Another (a family "dome" type) tent that I had suffered pole breakage when hit by a particularly strong wind gust. I wasn't around when it happened, and returned to a fallen tent. Because I wasn't there, I don't know how strong the gust was, but judging by the wind later that day, it was very strong. It required repair of the broken poles, and patching of a couple small holes, and was still very usable. I bought a repair kit at Walmart that had what I needed in it to fix the poles, and I just used duct tape to cover the small hole in the rain fly. A year or two later I gave it away to a friend who still has it, as far as I know.
Another source for a great selection of tents is Cabelas. They have many different types from basic tents like those at Walmart to "wall tents" that are intended to be used for several weeks at a time (or longer) during all kinds of weather. For durability during most kinds of weather, a canvas tent will be superior to a nylon or polyester tent. The major trade-off is weight, since canvas tents weigh significantly more than their synthetic counterparts. Kodiak and Springbar are two well known brands of canvas tents.
The other suggestion to ignore the claimed sleeping capacity is a good one. Take those numbers with a grain of salt. They are based solely on square footage, calculated by dividing total square footage by the space "required" for one person. This requirement takes into account only room to lie down, not room to move, room for equipment, room to change, and so on. If you are sleeping on pads on the ground, you can probably cut the number in half to achieve a reasonable person calculation. If using air mattresses or cots, cut it even further, possibly as much as 1/3 of the stated capacity. For myself and my two teenagers, we use a 16 x 10 tent for the three of us. This allows adequate room for cots, luggage, a place to change, etc. It doesn't feel particularly large, even though this tent is rated to sleep eight people, if I remember correctly.
If you want some privacy for the adults, consider getting a two room tent. If you do so, make sure there's enough space in each room to accommodate the sleeping needs of all the occupants. There are even some tents that have two rooms in addition to a screen room, though I can't think of who makes them at the moment. I believe I've seen this arrangement in the Cabelas catalog. Another option is a separate screen house, which can be where you go to eat, or just to escape bugs, if needed.